„Muhammad is the most influential man in history“

29. Februar 2012 85

CT-Interview with ex-Muslim Ali Sina about his planned Muhammad biopic

The Quran and the life of the Islamic prophet Muhammad – Image: Dieter Schütz / pixelio.de

Ali Sina is one of the best known American Islam critics and ex-Muslims. He is a board member of Stop Islamization of Nations (SION) an organization founded by Robert Spencer and Pamela Geller. Sina has enabled thousands of Muslims to renounce Islam. Now he wants to make a film about the life of the alleged prophet Muhammad. Citizen Times Editor in Chief Felix Strüning spoke to him about Muhammad biographies and the dangers of such a film project (German version at blu-News).

Citizen Times: Mr. Sina, you just published the idea, to produce a movie about the Islamic prophet Muhammad. Why?

Ali Sina: I want the truth be known. Muhammad is the most influential man in history. Not only he transformed much of the countries of Asia and Africa he also greatly influenced the western world.  Few people know that the demise of the classical civilization, the crusades, the inquisition, the conquistadores, communism, fascism, Nazism, secret societies, and even the Mafia owed their existence to the influence of Islam.

Today, the western countries that had a long tradition of tolerance are becoming less tolerant. That too is an influence of Islam. People in these countries feel under siege and are reacting. With thinkers such as Zakaria Razi, Farabi, Ibn Sina, Khayyam and others Persia was on the verge of enlightenment one thousand years ago.  Islam nipped that in the bud.  Think where we would be today if enlightenment happened five hundred years sooner. Those are lost centuries.

Without Muhammad the world would have been a different place – a much safer, gentler and enlightened place. And yet we know so little about this man. He is shrouded in mystery and myths.

Citizen Times: But there are a few good biographies at least the modern ones…

Ali Sina: The original books of history of Muhammad (known as sira) are voluminous and contain a lot of garbage such a miracles that his followers attributed to him, thousands of Arabic names that are unfamiliar to non-Muslim readers and a lot of useless information  like the long list of the people who migrated to Abyssinia or the early Yathrebi converts, etc.

Furthermore, to truly understand Muhammad you have to have an insight into his mind.  Muhammad’s story is compiled by his devout followers. You can’t trust everything they say about him. Ibn Hisham who made a recension of ibn Ishaq’s sira admitted that he omitted parts of it that he thought may hurt the sensitivities of the believers. Although the original text of Ibn Ishaq is lost, fortunately some of it is saved by other historians such as Tabari. One such example is the killing of Umm Qirfa. She was the leader of her tribe and an elderly woman of courage and wisdom. Ibn Hisham says she was captured and killed cruelly. The details of that cruelty are described by Tabari. Tabari says that her legs were tied to two ropes and each rope was pulled by a camel until she was ripped in two.

To get the full picture, you have to read at least the sira of Ibn Ishaq, the history of Tabari and the Tabaqat of Ibn Sa’d and have a good knowledge of the Quran.  That is thousands of pages to read.  Reading alone is not enough. You must also be able to separate the wheat from the chaff and for that you have to know what you are looking for.  You must become like a detective who goes through a pile of junk to find bits and pieces that will help him to put the puzzle together and make sense of what happened.

Citizen Times: Do you think you have put the puzzle about Muhammad together?

Ali Sina: Yes I think I have. I have studied Muhammad for years from a psychological point of view. I know about his disorders and what motivated him. Without that insight you can’t know Muhammad.  You can see that many of the things he did were very evil, but there are also things that make you believe he was sincere and believed in his cause.  The mystery can be solved only when you realize that he was affected by a series of mental disorders.  Only then you can make sense of what he did and what was the source of his conviction.

Citizen Times: Will there be a written biography accompanying this movie?

Ali Sina: Yes I am working on a book about the life of Muhammad. It follows the same story line of the movie. It is more detailed and is explained. It will be ready before the launch of the movie. It is one thing to tell people about what happened and quite another is to explain why it happened.

Citizen Times: How do you plan to get the necessary people together? It’s a dangerous job to join such a project…

Ali Sina: Now we have technology that allows us to shoot this movie without putting any one’s life in danger.  We can make it in 3D, like the movie Tintin or change the features of the actors digitally, like the movie Avatar. No one in the cast or the crew needs to reveal his or her identity.

Citizen Times: The movie What the West Needs to Know about Islam already gives a good insight. Why do we need another movie?

Ali Sina: What the West Needs to Know about Islam is a documentary.  The movie I am proposing is a biopic. A documentary attracts a certain type of viewers. That is the kind that reads and is already aware of the problem. A feature film attracts masses. It is the masses that I want to reach. I want people of all walks of life to see this movie for its entertainment value. I want ordinary people in the street, in offices, and kids in colleges talk about Muhammad. A feature film has a much wider audience than a documentary.  People don’t pay money to watch documentaries, but they pay for feature films. Now we have the means to get our message to the masses and nothing can reveal the truth about Islam more than revealing the truth about Muhammad.

If we manage to do this movie right and make it accessible to large numbers of people, it will change the discourse about Islam forever.  It would be impossible for the dhimmi media and politicians to deceive the public once the world knows the truth.  This may change everything.

Citizen Times: Do you think that Muslims will watch it too?

Ali Sina: Yes of course. Muslims are inquisitive like everyone else and they don’t want to live in a lie. They think they have found the truth and that is why they don’t listen. But once the movie is out and the world is talking about it, they will want to see it too and when they do the world will no longer be the same for them.  They can’t dismiss it as lies because there will be a footnote giving reference to the sources of the stories.

I have helped countless Muslims to leave Islam. First they deny everything, but truth is more powerful.  They can’t deny forever. One Bahraini person wrote that he and his brother used to send DOS attack to cripple my server. Eventually he started reading the articles on faithfreedom.org and left Islam. I am certain this movie will help millions of Muslims to see the light and that will be the beginning of an avalanche.  If we get the truth to the masses, we can get rid of Islam in a very short time.

Citizen Times: How do you plan to handle the expecting Islamic protests against crew, producing companies and cinemas?

Ali Sina: The crew and the cast can remain anonymous. We will use CGI to change their features and make them look like Arabs. This will allow us also to make them age. As for distribution, we may show the movie in theaters that are safe, such as in China or in select cities where Muslims don’t pose a major threat.  However, this movie will generate a lot of controversy and because of its explosive story many people will want to see it. We will take advantage of ancillary windows for distribution such as home entertainment. That is a huge window and growing.

We are living in a rapidly changing world. Theaters and bookstores are becoming less of a factor for the success of movies and books. More books and movies are sold online and digitally downloaded.   Technology has come to our help. A few years ago it would have been impossible to make such a movie or make a profit from it. Now we can do both.

Ali Sina (2008/2011): Understanding Muhammad and Muslims. A psychobiography. More information at: www.alisina.org


  1. Ali Sina 1. März 2012 at 07:41 - Reply

    Thank you for this interview. There is one error. I am not a founder of SION. I am a board member. The founders of Sion are Pamela Geller, Anders Gravers and Robert Spencer.

    • Felix Strüning 1. März 2012 at 11:28 - Reply

      Thanks, I changed it.

  2. Lenya 1. März 2012 at 11:19 - Reply

    I cant wait for the movie to be released. There are many people in the Pacific region at least more than 10 million people who have geographically never been influenced by Islam. This kind of film will stop Islam from spreading to them. More power to Al Sina’s film project.

  3. christian 1. März 2012 at 12:40 - Reply

    I wish that this movie will be made in Arabic, the language Muhammad and his companions spoke. Also the language of the Quran. Mel Gibson would be the best to direct it. Even if he is not interested I think it’s a good idea that Ali Sina would talk to him about this project.

  4. blacklaws 1. März 2012 at 14:30 - Reply

    Can’t wait to see it. The hell will breaks free, countless Muslims will renounce their faith. Proud to live in this era of massive apostasy. Proud to be kafir.

  5. joy 1. März 2012 at 17:04 - Reply

    It is a project well thought of. But I wonder what effect this move will have on the masses for whom it is intended because they are always in the denying mode. I have read in the past some of the debates which Mr. Sina had with the so-called muslim scholars and have seen the level to which they stoop down to defend their wicked prophet. I wish Ali Sina all success in this endeavour.

  6. Ali Sina 1. März 2012 at 18:47 - Reply

    Hi everyone and thanks for the support. Once the movie is done it does not take much to translate it many other languages and it is also easy to show it in any Islamic country. The Internet is the answer. Movies can be downloaded just as text, and yes I believe many Muslims in all Islamic countries will be able to view it.

    • AV 7. März 2012 at 20:51 - Reply

      Muslims will never learn their lesson Mr. Sina. They will protest. We fear sometimes thinking of banning your site by our so called secular Goverment.
      Though your movie is an awesome idea. It will be the best Service for mankind and Humanity.

  7. Malay Kumar 1. März 2012 at 20:24 - Reply

    Sir Ali Sina, I have great respect for scholars like you, so I am here for few suggestion. There is no use of making a movie as such…by any means it will be not released in my country(India- a banana republic)…before you release the movie the government will be out to stop your movie…and I bet the one who will do….will be hindus rather than muslims…because this is what happens here. In India, if a muslim kill hindu its simply another crime but if its hindu fighting a muslim, its opression of minorities, hate towards a community(even if the reason is for a chocolate between two 5 year kids)…they have reservations, special privilages but still they say India is not safe for them.

    Sir, one more thing, if your movie is released there will be more bomb blasts and riots, and you will be blamed, so pleases stick to your website only.

    sorry, my english is not good and I apologize for advising a scholar like you, but I am doing that out of respect.

    Thank you.

    • Shankar 15. November 2012 at 13:50 - Reply

      Malay Kumar,

      I perfectly agree with you. I am also from India and I want the Islam to end. Do you know that India is the only country in the world which Islam conquered but were not able to destroy Hinduism. Thanks for writing my thoughts.

      • Tariq 11. Dezember 2012 at 13:25 - Reply

        Shankar, I’m also from India. And I’ll agree with you that Islam couldn’t really change India. Consider these as Islam’s failure: 1). over 10 million female foetuses aborted over the last 2 decades. Of the 12 million girls born, 1 million don’t get to see their first birthday. 2) Every 20 minutes, a girl is raped. 3) Every 18 hours a bride is burnt alive for want of dowry. 4) In 2006, Indians had more black money, $ 1.5 billion, in Swiss banks alone than that from the rest of the world combined. 5) In Rajasthan, lower caste Hindus were asked by temple priest to eat cow dung to purify themselves before entering the temple. 6) My Hindu colleague from Bihar recalls that in his childhood, he used to see some people moving on roads with brooms and drums. They’d beat the drum to caution others on the road of their lower caste and sweep the road of their footprints so that upper caste people won’t have to tread over them. 6) In Haryana, Khap Panchayats prefer to kill young lovers before they elope to marry according to their wishes. Well, I’m lucky my great grandfather left Hinduism and converted to Islam. Incidentally, I’m married to a woman, whose father and over 20 relatives left Hinduism for Islam. So whatever you may wish, Islam is here to stay and advance. No amount of effort from you, Ali Sina and Geller can stop Islam from spreading.

    • lakshmi narayanan 14. Januar 2013 at 22:03 - Reply

      When BJP government comes – india will become truly secular … this movie will be shown in india – with passage of uniform civil code. Narendra Modi can and will do it

  8. Ali Sina 1. März 2012 at 23:19 - Reply

    Dear Malay Kumar,

    I understand your concern. But the movie wil be downloaded from the Internet in the same way that anti Islam books are downloaded. No one can stop the Internet because it does not belong to anyone. No will will know who made the movie. I am the only name behind it and it is not a Danish or Canadian or Indian name. Whom are they going to bomb? If they have learned their lesson they will keep quite and pretend never heard of it.

    • Shankar 15. November 2012 at 13:53 - Reply

      Dear Dr Ali Sina,

      You are worderfully knowledgeable and courageous person who is out to expose the hoax called Islam. You are welcome in your efforts. Please send a link to my website as to how I can contribute for your film. I dont have much money but will try. Best of lucks for your anti-Islam tirade which is certainly a curse on the modern society of free speech and expression. Islam destroyed so many cultures, so many religions, so many races. Keep up the good work. May the force of all good be with you.

    • Tariq 11. Dezember 2012 at 13:54 - Reply

      Ali Sina, I wouldn’t know you if I hadn’t clicked on a google link by mistake. There was this ‚Innocence of Muslims‘ video on the internet which created a storm worldwide. And the guy who made it, was arrested for fraud. That’s the distinction of people like you – making a movie against Islam, while cheating the world. BTW, you don’t count, you’re as insignificant as a spec of dust. Keep enjoying your kufr, for the rest of whatever life you’re left with.

      • GeertWilders4president 16. April 2013 at 23:35 - Reply

        The innocence of muslims was, indeed, a parody. But Sina has a serious project. He doesn’t means to offend you, he want help people like you to see the truth behind your’religion‘
        If you don’t want to see it, is maybe because you’re so insecure toward your faith?

  9. Boni 4. März 2012 at 07:54 - Reply

    This surely will reqiure tremendous amount of money even for hollywood standard. Has Ali had investors line up ?

  10. Ukumo Khalid 4. März 2012 at 08:34 - Reply

    Powerful Ali Sina, the man of the Milinium.

  11. Ukumo Khalid 4. März 2012 at 09:00 - Reply

    Ali Sina, translation of the movie in Arabic is of atmost importance and has to be a priority, please. Our Darfurian brothers know only arabic, do not know english, are all die-hard Muslims, are massacred by arabs/islam, and are all very poor, illitrate, their most educated have very low education at best and can only read the Quraan. They have abandoned their names, language and culture for that of Arabs. They will be shocked. .

  12. Frankie Lee 6. März 2012 at 03:48 - Reply

    This Muhammed film by Ali Sina is a great contribution for all human beings,and will change demonic cultures into one of sanity and common sense.

  13. arish sahani 11. März 2012 at 22:20 - Reply

    How people can be fooled for 1400 yrs.
    Why people should follow a sick minded and bad idealogy where your own women suffer .
    Don’t they have any intellectuals born after him that no one can get rid of his influence, his teaching.
    Why west is not doing enough to reach these sick minds and change them by freedom to think but letting their teaching influence our children and education system

  14. arish sahani 11. März 2012 at 22:24 - Reply

    Public Tv channel 13 stations all over the world should take this project to make a movie on Mohammad .
    many like me will fund this as it will be tax deductible.

  15. Roblé Gelle 16. März 2012 at 00:54 - Reply

    Iam an exmolem and i cant wait your futur movie Mr Sina and too thank you so much for your hard work for all.

  16. Vaikunth 16. März 2012 at 20:11 - Reply

    Thats great work, still it seems 2 b very risky task for u…..The whole world is waiting 2 know the truth. We would like to know, when its going to b release? Can we expect this or next year?Cant wait for.

  17. Muslim 10. April 2012 at 07:06 - Reply

    Islam survived all the years.
    Ali Sina can do something else.
    Enemies can’t harm Islam.

    • lakshmi narayanan 14. Januar 2013 at 22:07 - Reply

      islam is just 1400yrs – and already in fall – may be at max 30 years.

  18. Is this a good Idea? 11. April 2012 at 06:04 - Reply

    Dear Ali Sina,

    I am not sure if this is a good idea. Yes, I know it’s high time to let people know the dangers of Islam but you’ve asked one of the person who will the Muslims bomb. Well, do you think they have that large a brain to logically think and tell us. They will bomb everything and cause a huge havoc.

    But, I wish you all the very best in bringing out a fantastic feature film. Hope China really does take this out!

  19. Human 12. April 2012 at 11:43 - Reply

    Mr. Ali Sina, you’re doing a great job. But please make sure the film is translated (dubbed) in as many languages as possible around the world. Also, please try to make a point through this film as a conclusion, that the only way for muslims and non-muslims to stay in peace is that all the muslims leave islam and become HUMAN BEINGS. Also, please make the most basic fact CLEARLY DECLARED in the film, that quran and islam have no scope for modification or moderation at all, as both of these are wicked, violent, hateful and devilish enough to kill and finish any effort of modifying or moderating them, which means, A FINAL ENDTO ISLAM AND QURAN, AND A PERMANENT BAN UPON BOTH OF THEM is the ONLY WAY OUT, that humanity can exist in this world. (If I want to communicate with you personally, how can I do the same Mr. Sina?)

  20. dave 15. April 2012 at 14:15 - Reply

    Ali is expert and knows exactly what he is doing it and how he will do it. Let’s leave him to it.

    And I like him and everyone else understand the significance his film will have, knowing how knowledgeable and effective he is from his website, and the significance of the need it fills, and look forward to it greatly.

    I agree Ali I think we can get rid of islam in a very short time. And there are now many millions of amateurs, and many thousands of experts determined and devoted to helping shorten the time it takes to help islam be broken and a left behind belief by the majority of muslims and muslim countries.

    Good luck with the film and I wish for it as soon as you can, but of course do the best job you can and so take the time you need to do the best you are happy with.

  21. Mooch rim 28. April 2012 at 01:29 - Reply

    Mr. Ali Sina, if you honestly think that this movie will stop the spread of Islam, your sadly mistaken. 100 years from now, there will be Muslims in the world than any other religion in existence. Theres nothing we can do about it. Good luck though.

  22. A Hindu 16. Mai 2012 at 09:50 - Reply

    Dear Sina ji,
    First of all – All the best for your forthcoming project

    Maybe I sound negative, these Mullas like Imam Bukhari, New Delhi and our Hyderabad Muslim brothers will raise a banner that their beloved Prohet has been wrongly depicted etc etc and their followers might follow them like herd of goats – Have you thought about that?
    In Islamic countries – definetly this movies will be banned in all forms – even downloading from internet am not sure. Am not able not able to lay my hands on ‚Satanic Verses‘ here in India… I hope you understand what I mean and hence factor those also.
    A Hindu

    • Kyle 15. September 2012 at 03:22 - Reply

      Hey Hindu,
      I thought you seek peace
      Hey Ali why did u leave Islam?? why is this hatred man.
      Come on guys, what is with Islam that scares u all

      • Tariq 11. Dezember 2012 at 13:40 - Reply

        Hindu and peace! Before assuming anything about hinduism, just look at the images of their gods. All of them are armed with daggers, swords, machete, spears, bows. If they had rifles and tanks then, you’d probable see some of these gods with new weapons. And there’s a godess with a severed human head in one hand, with blood dripping from it, and blood soaked sword in the other hand. Godess Kali, if I remember the name correctly. And not to forget the black stone, Shivaligam, which putting politely, is the genital of god shaped to look like penetrating female sex organ. Hindus pour milk over it to mimick semen entering vagina. I just can’t imagine anything more absurd. Yet these Hindus have the audacity to foul-mouth Islam.

  23. Allen Wang 15. Juli 2012 at 14:35 - Reply

    Haha! Here in philippines, the no. 1 producer and seller of pirated cd/dvd’s are Muslims. I wonder if they will do the same thing with this movie. (:

  24. Amir 22. Juli 2012 at 16:14 - Reply

    People like Sina were in the time of Muhammad (Peace be upon him) too and the Holy Quran (the only book in its real condition for more than 1400 years) has called them the terrorists and the liers. A man with mental disorders cannot build the best society, the best laws and the best way of living by surving humanity, he was the best and biased people like you may never look into his mind. So if you think you can spit on moon .. be ready with a handkerchief because its gonna return on your face.

  25. Malay kumar 1. August 2012 at 00:39 - Reply

    If u consider the laws made by ur Prophet to be the best, ur society to be the best, ur educatiion, culture, language as best than stop going to western countries nd feed ur family on der expenses…nd please stop using internet ur Muhammad didn’t invent it it’s a kaffir technology…neway Hinduism & Christianity r older den Islam, so going by ur logic of 1400 yrs dey r better.

  26. muslim 4 ever 11. September 2012 at 20:35 - Reply

    [Taubah 9:32]
    They wish to extinguish the light of Allah with their mouths, but Allah will not agree except that He will perfect His light, even if the disbelievers get annoyed

    • Kyle 15. September 2012 at 03:25 - Reply

      few words mean more than a 1000 word…
      though I dont know that much about religion…. I think that muslims and hindu share many features except for the COW thing (sorry guys, no offense intended) but I do appreciate a cow seeking peace

  27. muslima 12. September 2012 at 12:54 - Reply

    Islam remains despite total Muhammad peace be upon him is supervised creation and God is Hafiz’s religion if not Muhammad’s greatest figure in history as exposure to this, but in spite of all these campaigns religion to Islamist is the most widely accepted in the world and the number of Muslims is always on the rise, especially after these campaigns, LA ILAH ILA ALLH MOHAMAD RASOULE ALLH

    • GeertWilders4president 16. April 2013 at 23:39 - Reply

      Poor muslim woman.

  28. cd mock 15. September 2012 at 00:11 - Reply

    Jesus, the only Son of the „Living“ God is the Most influential individual in all Eternity. Before Mohammed was, „Jesus Is“ Mohammed’s body rotted. Jesus Is alive forevermore. And Is coming back to judge the quick & dead. Including Mohammed.

  29. Maya 15. September 2012 at 01:31 - Reply

    It is shame on you Ali to speak in such a way at any religion not to mention Islam. I would like to know how much you are paid to get this movie done? and why are u scared that much of the spread of Islam. I believe that you are another barking dog who like publicity. You should be ignored as well as your movie. Why dont you make an anti Hindu Movie or anti Christ movie or you know what anti David movie so you will be ripped by the Jews and the Hindu.
    May your God (whoever that is) damn you for the rest of your life. Islam and other religions will continue until the end of this universe and u cant do anything about this because You ARE HELPLESS against good values whichever religion represents them.

  30. Huzefa 18. September 2012 at 16:26 - Reply

    Hi Ali, Great to hear that you are making this movie. just one query. You said that people from muslim countries can download the movie from Internet. But what if the web-site from which the movie can be downloaded is banned in islamic countries as it is happening with youtube? How are you going to tackle this. Hope your web-sites are up soon.

  31. JesusInside 20. September 2012 at 10:32 - Reply

    Sir Ali Sina.. billions are waiting to watch ur project & wish u all the best.. this „all the best“ is not because i’m a christian and may enjoy anti-islam rhetoric, but to know truth.. even after doing much hatred and killing to humanity, how Mohamed (pbuh) is revered as revered as most influential people on earth (as told by Michael Hart)? that also making Jesus to third place? are all we insane? at least, muslims can imagine they believe that Mohamed (pbuh) is dead and buried and will not come back.. But they believe JESUS IS STILL ALIVE AND WILL COME BACK ON JUDGEMENT DAY.. then why can’t they forget dead people and follow THE ONE WHO IS ALIVE FOREVER????? life of Jesus proves what he claimed.. he didn’t marry to a woman something to prove that relationship with a human being is too cheap for his glory.. but what about Mohamed (pbuh)?? Oh My God.. i can’t imagine.. Muslims are good people but I’m surprised know why they don’t use their brain to think about their religion??..

    • GeertWilders4president 16. April 2013 at 23:41 - Reply

      If you’re christian why you put (pbuh) after mo’s name?

  32. Ibn Umar 9ja 21. September 2012 at 18:30 - Reply

    Hi Ali sina! Muhammad (pbuh) lived with pple like u during his life time who are psycologically disorder even morethan u self. How i wish u were at that time? U ‚ll have been among those 2 aquired God’s anger & go astray! Ibn muqirah among others have tried their best to brings confusion into the muslim ummah but they never succeeded. I wish u same badluck! UP ISLAM…

  33. Reema 25. September 2012 at 16:02 - Reply

    what makes u think that the believers are going to stop believing in allah and our beloved prophet if u make a movie against Him. Muslims have believed him for the past 1400 years.. u still have no idea of their faith in islam.. u r a fool to think that their belief is as weak as urs.. islam has come across hundreds of ppl like u.. but sorry to say ur efforts are all going to be in vain..

  34. Bharat 27. September 2012 at 17:56 - Reply

    Best wishes and Luck for this noble project to educate the ignorant dhimmies and Muslims about Mohhamad the fake prophet.The truth will set us free and make retarded Muslims crazy.

  35. CoffeeArt 30. September 2012 at 07:17 - Reply

    Ali Sina, you are a blessing from God. Thank you. Brave souls like you will be remembered throughout history for helping to save this world from the scourge of Islamic insanity. Obama recently stated, „The future of this country does not belong to those who disrespect the prophet.“ It made chills run down my spine because I could see where this once great country was heading. However, your film will show the world that the truth will come out and evil will die of its own accord.

  36. Dilshad Ansari 6. Oktober 2012 at 22:50 - Reply

    Why to make a movie on Prophet (pbuh)?? If you want to expose,have a public debate on it.Let the whole world see. Dr. Zakir Naik from India will clear all your doubts/views whatever.Don’t come alone for debate,make sure all the scholors who you think may help in your cause,are also present there to debate.Not only you, if anybody has misconception about Isllam and its Prophet (pbuh) please refer to Dr. Zakir Naik at least for once.

  37. Angel 18. Oktober 2012 at 18:32 - Reply

    The end of the mayan calendar at 11:11 on the 21st Dec 2012, may signify an end to all organised religion and a move towards Universal Consciousness. Perhaps Ali Sina is instrumental in that process. If you look on Youtube under 11:11, you will see that more and more people are experiencing synchronicities in their lives in relation to this number. Perhaps we are living our lives in the ‚Matrix‘. Consciousness = information= Binary system (CPU).

  38. Adam 29. Oktober 2012 at 01:33 - Reply

    Mr sinner or whatever name you claimed you bear, there has been a challenge thrown to the world that anyone who doubt the words of the Qur’an let him or her produce a resemblance or better wordings for over 1400 yrs now! why dont you start from there. Islam, the Qur’an is from God and they are been guided by God. So no amount of your antics will affect it as it is with christenity and the bible today. It will better for you and your sponsors to look for some other meaningful venture than stagging a fight that could not be fought / won by any worldly being.

  39. KENNETH 21. November 2012 at 14:14 - Reply

    Adam, your allah and his rasool are incurable liars. Muhammad knew that anyone who would have contradicted him would have been branded an ‚enemy of allah and his apostle‘. The penalty would have been very gruesome death. Muhammad ordered people who merely satyred him to be put to death and others he called the enemies of allah and his apostle. It is only ossified brained muslims who fail to see the emptiness in the quran and the fact that the stories it contains have been hap hazardly copied from earlier works. I believe that the end of the satanic cult called islam will come. It may not be in our lifetime. But nobody foresaw such an early demise of communism. Dr. Sina is God sent and his sacrifices are appreciated by all decent human beings. He deserves our gratitude and support. MAY DR. ALI SINA LIVE LONG.

  40. Almustapha 27. November 2012 at 18:53 - Reply

    The number of europeans trooping to islam is quite disturbing to idol worshipers(christans) example from 2000 to 2010 the number of muslims in u.s.a rises from about 0.9m to 2.4m, in uk mahammad become the third most frequen name which people gives to there newborn bebies, janet jackson, henry and millions of people just throw away christianity to islam hahahahahahahahahaha who is losing The true or the false?

  41. Amin 22. Dezember 2012 at 05:27 - Reply

    “ Sina has enabled thousands of Muslims to renounce Islam.“

    „Ali Sina is one of the best known American Islam critics and ex-Muslims.“

    On what basis?

    His book for example – no one bothered to published.

    There is virtually NO ONE declaring that they were „liberated“ with the help of Sina.Yet they do declared they are ex-Muslim.

    So on what basis did you write these comments as the truth?

  42. jamel 3. Januar 2013 at 03:05 - Reply

    To keep an open mind, I realize that you cited few passages from Quran and few from Haddiths to judge The Prophet Muhammad Peace upon him, but you totally neglect to mention the numerous qualities and characteristics who made him the most influential person ever, please read Michael Hart: a Jewish writer what does he say about The Prophet, nobody can denies what a great human he was, even at time of war he show tremendous restraint against the enemy. Prophet Muhammad’s military activities were remarkably restrained compared to the genocidal bloodbaths gleefully endorsed in the Bible, where God’s holy warriors did not spare even women, children or infants. the Prophet did what no one expected him to do — he forgave his enemies and let them go. The true test of a man’s character is revealed when he has power, and the Prophet’s actions at the height of his power remain a shining example to Muslims and all human beings of taking the higher road when revenge would be easier and perhaps more satisfying. Another example and there hundred of them: Prophet’s honor, and one woman of Khaybar poisoned the meal. Several of the Prophet’s companions died, but the Prophet spit out the poisoned food before it could take effect. The assassin was captured and the Prophet asked the woman why she had done this deadly act. She shrugged and responded that Muhammad had defeated her tribe and she was simply avenging them.
    The Prophet forgave her and let her go.
    another example of his human qualities is: When he founded the Muslim community in Medina, he had drawn up a treaty with the Jews of the city, which guaranteed their freedom of religion and sought their alliance against the military attacks from Mecca. Please read more about the prophet to find out the real truth. I am also looking for the truth and believe me you cannot find it if you are only represent one side of the story, again Mr ali Sina, you tried to portrait a bad image of Islam, good try but next time try not to write only the bad side which I think can be debatable, try not to be biases and hateful, you are not doing any human a favor by explaining why you reject Islam, you did half ass job and I do apologize for saying this, look at this
    The world is a better place because Prophet Muhammad survived against his opponents and won. And even as the Prophet showed grace and clemency to his enemies, so must his heirs do so today. With the grace of God, Islam is an unstoppable force that will keep growing. That triumph is assured by history, demographics and its inherent attractiveness as a way of life for humanity. No filmmaker, artist, author, musician — or invading army — can destroy Islam. Secure in that knowledge, it is time for Muslims to relax and ignore the daily offenses and insults thrown at them by denizens of the cheap seats. It is time for Muslims to show the powerful confidence that Prophet Muhammad demonstrated when he had won and his enemies trembled at his feet. The power that comes from three simple words.
    I forgive you.
    another MICHAL HART WROTE ON THE MOST INFLUCIAL PERSON IN HISTORY: The first person on Hart’s list is the Prophet of Islam Muhammad.[2] Hart asserted that Muhammad was „supremely successful“ in both the religious and secular realms. He also believed that Muhammad’s role in the development of Islam was far more influential than Jesus. Please stop this propaganda against the most beloved person in the world and don’t waste your time, you are very naive and maybe stupid to think that you will succeed, Islam is here to stay and flourish more in the future and in the rest of the world.

  43. adewalesharoff 29. Januar 2013 at 12:26 - Reply

    This is not the first attempt and will not be the last attempt by people to mislead the ignorants about Islam, Muhammed (SAW) and the Muslims, all are to no avail. The best criticism is the one done with fact and proofs, not with sentiment and prejudise. And the end result is with God, the Almighty.

  44. Anon31 30. Januar 2013 at 02:39 - Reply

    Continue to live in denial and regret in the afterlife or have the guts to seek what’s truth & repent.

    I read , i worship and i pray words that i can truly understand and learn . Ask yourself , Do you sincerely understand everything in your book? Even if it was altered just yesterday, will you be able to notice any changes?

    I prefer the truth rather than follow one’s command of tradition.

  45. sajah 15. Februar 2013 at 23:43 - Reply

    you are a big fool Sina

  46. Mike 23. Februar 2013 at 19:17 - Reply

    In Vain, a Waste of Money and Time!!

    the more you do the worse you Get!!

    You are doing Islam a Very GOOD Favor!

    Thanx alot alleged ali sina for introducing OUR Beloved Prophet Moahmmed to the Millions of people that are never to hear of him without your help. pushing them to learn and study more about this MOST RESPECTFUL AND MOST INFLUENTIAL PERSON IN THE HISTORY.

  47. wafaaA 23. Februar 2013 at 21:23 - Reply

    U stupid sina, u r only wasting your time and energy islam for life and muhammad for ever till the world vanish

  48. David 7. März 2013 at 06:28 - Reply

    Sina let me tell you something my son, If Muhammad pbuh never existed you would not have come into existance. Meaning that Muhammad pbuh is the essence of life itself. But go ahead with your satanic attacks lets see where they get you when you are being questioned on the day of judgment. People like you come and go trying their best to say something as your probably a loner and wanted some attention. I actually feel sorry for you and pity you on the other hand you have wrote your own future in the afterlife hell awaits you:)

    • GeertWilders4president 16. April 2013 at 23:46 - Reply

      Oh! So I was right. You muslims are Mohammed workshipper, not Allah worksipper.

      Mohammed is a big self-insert ‚Mary-Sue‘
      Search on ‚television tropes and idioms and you will see what I mean.

  49. tarek itani 17. März 2013 at 04:18 - Reply

    You are wasting your time, many people already tried to change mohammads pbuhs image.The result is more and more muslims . Wether you like it or not no sheikh have ever converted to christianity , on the other hand millions of christian fathers convert to islam and i see them everyday because they want peace . U and ur satanic friends did september 11 to make a violent image of islam ,but never talk about what american jews and christians have did in iraq afghanstan , not 3000 people died but 100s of thousands. Like it or not ISLAM will rule the world one day. But dw islam have justice btween muslims and non muslims unlike todays satanic zionism.

  50. tarek itani 17. März 2013 at 04:25 - Reply

    Islam is the religion that gave women their rights they honored them ,u dont see muslim women on car magazine in bikinis just to sell more cars, or some more alcohol whatever .Islam has only one book and its the qraan ,one copy and its translated , unlike the bible that has a diff meaning in every edition and no one have ever memorized it. qraans miracle is that its memorized my friend .The arabic language has no capital letters and small letters and the quraan when translated becomes much more bigger , thats why its arabic.How on Earth u can conivnce people to belive in a god that human tortured him .

  51. oluwatoyin 5. Juli 2013 at 06:14 - Reply

    Fear ALLAH & base ur research on truth not senttlement

  52. izzydeen 30. Juli 2013 at 22:43 - Reply

    Honestly I was really astounded by people really believing that Islam can just wiped out of peoples hearts by just a movie and I am further surprised that some people actually believe in this Dr Sina.Mohammed (pbuh) was a human being just like the rest of us so Muslims do not and can never worship him.The appeal of Islam is based solely on the Quran and I can bet that as long as the Quran is still with us,Islam can only grow and which it is.Take a close look at Europe and see how these mosques are dotting the landscapes.Greece is the only surviving country in Europe that is still STRUGGLING to not allow for a mosque to be built on its soil.So really Dr Sina sorry to burst ur bubble I can rightly tell you now that your movie would only give popularity to Islam and make more people wanna take a closer look at it.So good luck in your attempt I would also watch it if I come accross it.I wish you and your fans the peace we Muslims the world over know.

  53. Abdulquadri 12. Oktober 2013 at 01:37 - Reply

    I would like to correct those who call you a scholar to stop it.because scholars normally think wisely.

  54. Mika'eel 21. November 2013 at 08:15 - Reply

    The Devil works through many men like you Sina. We have responded with nothing but truth and righteousness, you on the other hand, have made accusations with no proof at all. Muhammad is a mercy to mankind and we worship Our Creator only. Maybe it is that you would want us to worship Jesus (a man) and since we don’t you would like to discredit what we believe and can prove to be true (you cannot). This I tell you (you who will not see truth when it is in your face), „Muhammad and the Holy Quran is the truth by your God and mines. His personal name is Allah (even Jesus knew that) There is no god but Allah and Muhammad is his messenger. Salaam (Peace)

  55. Lukwago bashir 11. Dezember 2013 at 11:21 - Reply

    Mr sinner you can try watever you want but allah guaranteed his protection on his religion by the way what is ur religion . Islam is a religion of peace you can came with all you so called fact and debate them with the muslim learned scholars your are nothing compared to phraoh. And all that is illegal is done in the dark why hide the actors identity . Never has a muslim acted a movie against any other religion why do you always want to oppress muslim.may Allah guide you to the truth and save you from the shaytan’s intensios

  56. rehe 12. Dezember 2013 at 13:37 - Reply

    A CLOSED EYE NEVER SEES ANYTHING … Dr. Sina your work is great.

    „God/Allah is dead……“

  57. vinod sharma 23. Januar 2014 at 16:28 - Reply

    Mr.Ali Sina, I salute you & other ex muslims like you.Every religion has it’s share in destroying.damaging the world peace & humanity but ISLAM has no equal.My best wishes for the proposed movie & once again salute you.

  58. Reazul Haque 26. Februar 2014 at 13:00 - Reply

    This is the result of frustration of Mr.Sina. When nothing can be done on the question of the authenticity of Quran and superiority of the historical personality like Prophet Muhammad, you are making yourself a joke. Mind it, Muslims have come to influence people from darkness to light, some people may be misled by Satan like you.

  59. A.o.barre 1. April 2014 at 19:33 - Reply

    ali sina you can do whatever you want in this world.butk now for sure that the hypocrites like you will suffer in hellfire that is way painful than the one these kuffaars going to suffer.

  60. Maris Evans 21. April 2014 at 02:51 - Reply

    Minus the female prejudice factor, Islam is a noble religion. Anybody can lie or pretend. Why should we believe you? You just sound like the average prejudice person.
    I hope this movie of yours is seen as the stupidity it is.

  61. Zaharadeen 2. Mai 2014 at 00:31 - Reply

    I wonder what ur thinking ali sina,i wont say much, for all of u who are against islam you wil be suprise after the movie.i hope u wil even rich dat tym but all i want u to know is that islam wil take the world wheather u like it or not.(Allahu Akbar)

  62. Amy 12. Mai 2014 at 10:53 - Reply

    Pity – it’s a real pity. All I can do is pray to Allah to open your eyes, that are blinded by prejudice and racism. Ali, I can’t assume that you’ve never looked deeply and openly at Islam – because you’re a so-called „scholar“ – but the idea of this movie seems to be driven and influenced by fear. Not fear from Muslims and their „actions“, but rather fear that Islam will expand geographically – cowardly actions, really. People can argue now, I suppose, but the truth will come out eventually – it’s only a matter of time. *^.^* And please don’t take this as an insult, or a suggestion from a stranger, but, honestly, you should give up on trying to turn people away from Islam, because, in the end, you’ll realize that you’ve done almost nothing in your life, but dedicated your life to something that was bound to fail from the beginning. You really are not going to accomplish much with your „anti-islam“ movement – Islam is simply too powerful for you, and for people with the same ambition.

    ~Oh and one more thing: If you knew enough about Islam and Arabs, you wouldn’t even THINK about speaking about Arabs… why?!?! Because, although a majority of Arabs ARE Muslims, you’d know better than to even mention „Arabs“ in general, because A HUGE number of them are Christians, Jewish, Catholic, etc. You call yourself a scholar -haaa! I see success in this project already!! ~hence the sarcasm~ Lolz, I’ll just pray for you man, and even if I do wish you luck, it wouldn’t work! 。◕‿◕。

  63. Harish 21. Mai 2014 at 15:37 - Reply

    Ali Sina is the cool new Neo he is going to break the Matrix.

  64. Chris 8. Juni 2014 at 14:44 - Reply

    With so much blindness and ignorance, I wish to shed some light.
    Congratualtions Mr Sina, your work is extremely valuable to humanity. Many of us appreciate the difficulties in what you do (let only the insults from zombies).
    Please carry on with your film project – it does seem that the time is right to shine a beacon on the world’s most evil, corrupt and backward cult.

  65. Alhussein 13. Juli 2014 at 15:19 - Reply

    In the name of Allah, the Gracious, the Merciful.
    When the help of Allah comes, and the victory
    And thou seest men entering the religion of Allah in troops.

  66. Abdul Aziz 9. August 2014 at 12:20 - Reply

    Islam is preserved by Allah and Mohammed (SAW) was sent by Allah. Everything u do will only make Islam strong. U can say what ever u want, but Allah is most gracious most merciful, most loving and wise. Allah has purified Mohammed (SAW) and u and ur so called exMuslims are lost for ever. The Quran is preserved by Allah and no one can change a single letter from it. We Muslims are peace loving and we love such challenges because at the end more and more will convert to islam. An example for you is 9.11. Make ur research and u will find out that more people are converting to Islam since that day till now.

  67. T N Thomas 9. Juli 2015 at 11:27 - Reply

    Dear mr.sina. I respect your work and eagerly waiting to see the biopic. Good luck with this noble cause.

  68. iram 16. Januar 2016 at 20:14 - Reply

    Do whatever you want sina and his blind followers in this world, you’ll see what happens to you in the next. You are all doomed if you don’t repent now. Believe in the Truth and repent! If you think Islam is false then go and read about it with your eyes, ears, mind and hearts opened.

Leave A Response »